35 West Chester Street

StatusListed again

Off market sinceAugust 2026

Last asking price$3,800,000

AreaTown

Beds3

Baths1.5

Lot0.1885 acres

Year built1925

TypeSingle Family Residence

MLS #91936

Three bedroom antique home and garage nestled between West Chester Street and Sunset Hill Road. Set on an oversized lot this property has almost 2,000 square feet of remaining ground cover. Near Lily Pond Park and the Oldest House, it offers a level of privacy that is rare for properties in the Residential Old Historic District. The house is located within the highest portion of the lot, approximately 40 feet, along Sunset Hill Road, offering a nice view toward Lily Pond Park. The garage is situated just off West Chester at approximately 20 feet.

This listing has ended. The home is on the market again as MLS #93433.

For what is for sale in Town now, see the Town guide or all current listings.

Want the honest read on this one?

Sean walks these streets. Call or text for the story behind the listing — value, history, and what the photos don't show.

Call 508-228-4578 Text Sean

Listing courtesy of Great Point Properties · Liz Finlay. Data from LINK (Listing Information Network, Inc.) as of October 9, 2026. Information believed correct but not guaranteed; buyers should verify all details independently.

More about this home

35 West Chester Street, Nantucket — photo 1

35 West Chester Street, Nantucket — photo 2

35 West Chester Street, Nantucket — photo 3

35 West Chester Street, Nantucket — photo 4

35 West Chester Street, Nantucket — photo 5

35 West Chester Street, Nantucket — photo 6

35 West Chester Street, Nantucket — photo 7

THE KALMAN Co.

Nantucket, MA 02554 · 508-228-4578 · sean@thekalmanco.com · Brokered by eXp Realty