The Kalman Co.
ListingsInsightsAbout
Contact Sean
Homes · Land · Condos
Nantucket homes for sale
Try "Cisco, 4 beds, under $5M"
Houses
Any price
Search
All New this week Waterfront Under $3M Off-market
Featured properties — hand-picked by Sean · full live inventory under Search
Sort: Newest ▾ Search by map
47 Fair Street, Nantucket
Historic · Built 1808
$4,950,000
Town
47 Fair Street
4 beds4 baths2,447 sq ft
36 Easton Street, Nantucket
Harborfront · Pending
$28,500,000
Brant Point
36 Easton Street
9 beds9.5 baths4,959 sq ft
85 Orange Street, Nantucket
New construction
$7,695,000
Town
85 Orange Street
5 beds5.5 baths4,200 sq ft
43 Vestal Street, Nantucket
Heated pool · Renovated 2026
$7,995,000
West of Town
43 Vestal Street
4 beds5.5 baths2,954 sq ft
19 India Street, Nantucket
Historic · Built 1809
$8,250,000
Town
19 India Street
4 beds4.5 baths3,268 sq ft
59 South Shore Road, Nantucket
Surfside compound
$39,900,000
Surfside
59 South Shore Road & 14/14R Tripp Drive
8 beds8.5 baths10,147 sq ft
View all island listings →
Explore by neighborhood
All neighborhood guides →
Town
Cobblestones, historic homes, walk to everything
'Sconset
Rose-covered cottages and the eastern bluff
Cisco
Surf, farms, and the south shore
Madaket
Legendary sunsets on the west end
Surfside
Wide beaches, family compounds
Monomoy
Harbor views minutes from town
Wauwinet
Quiet luxury between harbor and ocean
Mid Island
Year-round living and smart value
Buying on Nantucket, decoded

Nantucket real estate does not behave like any other market. Homes can sell in a weekend, or sit for months and suddenly draw three offers. Financing on the island has its own rules, and the historic district, Title 5 septic requirements, and flood zone designations all shape what a property can become — and what it can cost you if you miss them.

Most Nantucket homes for sale today fall between $1M and $13M, and each price point carries its own dynamics, buyer pool, and negotiating logic. Spring and summer drive the highest activity; fall extends the window for serious buyers; winter is underrated — quieter inventory, motivated sellers, and opportunities with almost no competition.

A significant share of Nantucket island real estate never touches the public listings. It moves through relationships — between agents, families, and neighbors. That off-market network takes years to build, and it is one of the clearest advantages a sixth-generation Nantucketer brings to the table. Whether you're searching in Town, 'Sconset, Cisco, or Madaket, The Kalman Co. pairs deep island expertise with transparent data so you can move decisively.

Don't see the dream yet? A lot of the island moves off-market.
Call 508-228-4578 Text Sean
Home Listings Insights Talking Nantucket Neighborhood Guides Market Report Buying Guide Home Valuation About & Team Contact
The Kalman Co.
InstagramFacebookLinkedIn
508-228-4578 · sean@thekalmanco.com · Brokered by eXp Realty