THE KALMAN Co.
ListingsKnow NantucketAbout
Contact Sean
← All listings
MLS #93189
Town · Active · Listed June 22, 2026

39A Milk Street

$4,995,000
39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 1 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 2 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 3 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 4 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 5 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 6 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 7 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 8 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 9 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 10 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 11 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 12 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 13 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 14 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 15 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 16 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 17 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 18 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 19 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 20 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 21 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 22 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 23 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 24 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 25 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 26 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 27 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 28 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 29 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 30 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 31 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 32 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 33 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 34 39A Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 35
35 photos · select any photo to open it full screen
5Bedrooms
5.5Baths · 5 full, 1 half
4,793Square feet
0.1558Acres · 6,790 sq ft
1790Built · renovated 2007
$1,042Per square foot
The home

Five bedrooms, renovated in 2007.

Call 508-228-4578Call SeanText Sean

Blending timeless Nantucket charm with modern living, this five-bedroom, five-and-a-half-bathroom home offers an exceptional retreat for family and friends.

Thoughtfully designed with multiple living areas and transitional spaces, this home provides both comfort and versatility. Conveniently situated near Main Street’s world-class shopping and dining, and just moments from the island’s most beloved South Shore beaches, this home combines rich Nantucket history with modern day convenience.

The inviting interiors total nearly 5,000 square feet of living space. The outdoor space includes a deck, patio, and parking. This property abuts Nantucket Land Bank property, extending peace and privacy to the backyard.

Floor by floor

A walk through the rooms.

First floor

The first floor offers a thoughtfully designed layout with two spacious en suite bedrooms. There is also a powder room. Multiple living areas—including a formal living room, a cozy sitting room, and a more casual gathering space—provide both flexibility and flow, complemented by two fireplaces that create warmth and character throughout. A formal dining area anchors the home for entertaining, while the recently renovated kitchen, complete with pantry and adjacent laundry, seamlessly blends modern function with timeless style. Sliding doors open to the back patio, inviting effortless indoor-outdoor living with space for al fresco dining and relaxation.

Second floor

The second floor includes a primary suite, complete with a recently renovated bathroom featuring a double vanity, modern tiled shower, and a separate soaking tub for spa-like relaxation. Overlooking the main level, a balcony adds architectural interest and a sense of openness to the home. A spacious, second en suite bedroom completes this floor, offering comfort and privacy.

Details

Everything on the record.

StatusActive
ListedJune 22, 2026
Days on market111
Original price$5,195,000
MLS #93189

The house

TypeSingle Family Residence
Rooms12
Bedrooms5 · 2 on the main level
Bathrooms5 full, 1 half
Living area4,793 sq ft
Year built1790
Renovated2007
FurnishedFurnished
Fireplace2
Flooring3 - Wide Pine

Systems and exterior

HeatingGas, forced hot water
AmenitiesA/C, Disposal, Insulation, Irrigation
BasementThe lower level provides a generous extension of living space; featuring a casual; open living area. A spacious en suite bedroom offers privacy and comfort; while a versatile flex room can be tailored to your needs—whether as an additional bedroom; home office; or cozy den. Ample storage throughout ensures practicality without compromising style; making this level both functional and inviting.
FoundationPoured Concrete
ExteriorPorch, Patio
GarageNo
Private poolNo
ViewResidential

Land, taxes and fees

Lot0.1558 acres (6,790 sq ft)
Lot featuresUtility easement recorded at the Nantucket Registry of Deeds in Book 1099 Page 41.
ZoningR1
SewerTown
WaterTown
Assessed value$2,588,600
Annual tax$11,016 · tax year 2025

Want the honest read on this one?

Sean walks these streets. Call or text for the story behind the listing — value, history, and what the photos don't show.

Text SeanCall 508-228-4578
Location

Town, on the map.

Full island map →
This home is the navy pin · lighter pins are other current listings nearby
Town on the island guideThe streets, the market and what it is like to live there.Talking Nantucket, the blogWhat Sean is seeing on the island this month.What’s on Nantucket this weekEvents, openings and the market at a glance.

Near this one in price and place.

All listings →
47 Fair Street, Nantucket
$4,950,000
Town
47 Fair Street
3 beds4 baths0.0756 acres
Listing: William Raveis Nantucket
20 Straight Wharf #B, Nantucket
Condo
$4,299,900
Town
20 Straight Wharf #B
2 beds2.5 baths0.07 acres
Listing: J Pepper Frazier Co.
33.5 Vesper Lane, Nantucket
$5,750,000
Town
33.5 Vesper Lane
6 beds5 baths0.1723 acres
Listing: J Pepper Frazier Co.
29 Milk Street, Nantucket
$4,195,000
Town
29 Milk Street
4 beds2.5 baths0.123 acres
Listing: BHHS Island Properties Nantucket

Listing courtesy of William Raveis Nantucket · Amy Sanford. Data from LINK (Listing Information Network, Inc.) as of October 15, 2026. Information believed correct but not guaranteed; buyers should verify all details independently.

Explore
HomeListingsOpen HousesNeighborhood Guides
Insights
Know NantucketTalking NantucketMarket Report
Guides
Buying GuideSelling GuideHome ValuationAll Island Guides
Company
About & TeamContact
THE KALMAN Co.
InstagramFacebookLinkedIn
Nantucket, MA 02554 · 508-228-4578 · sean@thekalmanco.com · Brokered by eXp Realty
© 2026 The Kalman Co. · Equal Housing Opportunity