THE KALMAN Co.
ListingsKnow NantucketAbout
Contact Sean
← All listings
MLS #93563
West of Town · Active · Listed November 5, 2026

71 Milk Street

$12,795,000
71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 1 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 2 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 3 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 4 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 5 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 6 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 7 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 8 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 9 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 10 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 11 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 12 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 13 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 14 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 15 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 16 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 17 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 18 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 19 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 20 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 21 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 22 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 23 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 24 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 25 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 26 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 27 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 28 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 29 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 30 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 31 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 32 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 33 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 34 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 35 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 36 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 37 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 38 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 39 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 40 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 41 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 42 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 43 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 44 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 45 71 Milk Street, Nantucket — photo 46
46 photos · select any photo to open it full screen
5Bedrooms
6.5Baths · 5 full, 3 half
4,656Square feet
0.9985Acres · 43,499 sq ft
1993Built · renovated 2016
$2,748Per square foot
The home

Five bedrooms, renovated in 2016.

Call 508-228-4578Call SeanText Sean

Rarely does a Nantucket property combine first-floor views of Nantucket Sound, exceptional privacy, proximity to Town, and significant future potential.

Set on an elevated one-acre parcel, 71 Milk Street offers a rare opportunity to experience the best of island living, with distant water views, refined interiors, and beautifully landscaped grounds. The residence features five generously sized en-suite bedrooms, thoughtfully designed living spaces, and timeless finishes that blend classic Nantucket character with modern sophistication.

Outdoors, a private pool, hot tub, cabana, and inviting entertaining areas create a secluded retreat surrounded by lush landscaping. With over 3,300 square feet of remaining ground cover, the property also presents an exceptional opportunity for future expansion and customization.

From spectacular sunsets over Nantucket Sound to leisurely summer afternoons spent poolside, every aspect of the property captures the essence of Nantucket living. Ideally located just moments from Town and along the route to the beloved Cisco area, 71 Milk Street offers convenient access to Nantucket's historic downtown, Cisco Beach, Cisco Brewers, Bartlett's Farm, and Miacomet Golf Club.

This property spans from Milk Street to Vestal Street with frontage on both.

Floor by floor

A walk through the rooms.

First floor

The first floor can be accessed through the traditional front entry or a convenient mudroom and immediately impresses with its stunning finishes, exceptional craftsmanship, and thoughtful attention to detail throughout. An inviting, open-concept kitchen, living, and dining area offers an elegant yet comfortable setting for everyday living and entertaining. Beautifully appointed interiors, refined architectural details, and high-quality materials create a sophisticated aesthetic while maintaining the warmth and charm of a Nantucket home. French doors off the living room open to a spacious deck with sweeping views toward Nantucket Sound, seamlessly connecting the interior living spaces with the outdoors. An additional sitting area, framed by expansive windows, provides an idyllic setting to take in the spectacular sunsets and distant water views. The first-floor primary suite is equally impressive, featuring beautiful finishes, extensive custom built-ins, blackout shades, a walk-in closet, and a luxurious en-suite bathroom. A thoughtfully appointed powder room completes this level.

Second floor

The second floor offers two spacious en-suite bedrooms, both with views of Nantucket Sound and beautifully appointed bathrooms.

Details

Everything on the record.

StatusActive
ListedNovember 5, 2026
MLS #93563

The house

TypeSingle Family Residence
Rooms11
Bedrooms5 · 1 on the main level
Bathrooms5 full, 3 half
Living area4,656 sq ft
Year built1993
Renovated2016
FurnishedPartially
Fireplace1
FlooringOak

Systems and exterior

HeatingGas, forced hot air
AmenitiesA, A/C, Insulation, Irrigation, Outdoor shower
BasementThe lower level offers an inviting entertainment space with a pool/ping pong table; beverage drawers; ice maker; and comfortable lounge area. Direct access to a sunken patio and grilling area provides a seamless connection to the pool and outdoor living spaces. This level also features a powder room; spacious secondary laundry room; and two en-suite bedrooms; one with a king bed and the other with three custom built-in twin beds.
FoundationPoured Concrete
ExteriorPatio, Garden, Deck, Porch, P/Pool, H/Tub
Other structuresThere is a cabana by the pool with a powder room; beverage drawers; ice maker and ample storage. Also there is a shed along the driveway. A generator is along the path to the east side of the lot.
ParkingAmple
GarageNo
Private poolNo
ViewD/Snd

Land, taxes and fees

Lot0.9985 acres (43,499 sq ft)
ZoningR20
SewerTown
WaterWell
UtilitiesCable
Assessed value$2,734,200
Annual tax$10,883 · tax year 2026

Want the honest read on this one?

Sean walks these streets. Call or text for the story behind the listing — value, history, and what the photos don't show.

Text SeanCall 508-228-4578
Location

West of Town, on the map.

Full island map →
This home is the navy pin · lighter pins are other current listings nearby
West of Town on the island guideThe streets, the market and what it is like to live there.Talking Nantucket, the blogWhat Sean is seeing on the island this month.What’s on Nantucket this weekEvents, openings and the market at a glance.

Near this one in price and place.

All listings →
3 Wyers Way, Nantucket
$7,500,000
West of Town
3 Wyers Way
5 beds5 baths0.1836 acres
Listing: Great Point Properties
105 Low Beach Road, Nantucket
$12,995,000
Sconset
105 Low Beach Road
5 beds5 baths6.11 acres
Listing: William Raveis Nantucket
11 West Creek Road & 41.5 Nobadeer Farm Road, Nantucket
Commercial
$12,495,000
Mid Island
11 West Creek Road & 41.5 Nobadeer Farm Road
3 beds3.5 baths0.39 acres
Listing: J Pepper Frazier Co.
2 Birdsong Lane, Nantucket
$12,495,000
Town
2 Birdsong Lane
7 beds8 baths0.32 acres
Listing: Maury People Sotheby's International Realty

Listing courtesy of Maury People Sotheby's International Realty · William Maier. Data from LINK (Listing Information Network, Inc.) as of November 5, 2026. Information believed correct but not guaranteed; buyers should verify all details independently.

Explore
HomeListingsOpen HousesNeighborhood Guides
Insights
Know NantucketTalking NantucketMarket Report
Guides
Buying GuideSelling GuideHome ValuationAll Island Guides
Company
About & TeamContact
THE KALMAN Co.
InstagramFacebookLinkedIn
Nantucket, MA 02554 · 508-228-4578 · sean@thekalmanco.com · Brokered by eXp Realty
© 2026 The Kalman Co. · Equal Housing Opportunity