October matched September's 51 sales and beat its dollars by forty million — $280.3 million, the year's biggest month — on a $35 million Cliff sale and a $4.75 million median, while the island's inventory fell for a third month running.
Fifty-one sales closed for $280,290,000 in October, more than any other month of 2026 and $40 million clear of September's $240.6 million on exactly the same number of trades, on 46 home sales, three lots and two commercial properties. A year ago, October 2025 closed 65 sales for $372.4 million; this October did three-quarters of that money on fourteen fewer trades, because the homes that sold were a good deal pricier — a $4,747,500 median against $3,850,000, up 23.3% — and because 5 Grant Avenue on the Cliff closed at $35,000,000, the largest sale of the year by ten million dollars. Homes captured 97.2% of their last asking price by LINK's count; the 39 that were publicly listed averaged 96.7%, and thirteen of them closed at or above it.
Inventory thinned a third time. The island ended October with 143 listings, down 7% from September and the lowest month-end count since April, and the standing residential shelf fell from 123 homes to 106, which took residential absorption from five months to three at October's pace. Thirty-four new listings arrived, one more than September and 42% more than last October; the 25 residential ones came on at a median ask of $3,995,000, three-quarters of a million under what sold and two million under the $5,995,000 median of what was already for sale. Twenty-six listings changed price during the month, up from September's 17, and 24 came off the market, more than twice September's 11 — the shelf is being cleared from both ends.
Put the median that sold next to what's being asked, and the gap closed from the sales side: October's pricier closings pulled the sold median up toward the shelf, while the new sellers of October priced under both.
Three declines in a row now. The island carried fewer listings at the end of October than at any month-end since April, and the homes on the shelf thinned fastest of all — 106 at month-end, from 157 in July.
Land stayed quiet: three parcels, one of them private, at a median 15% above last October's. The top of the market did the opposite of quiet.
The island-wide median tells you less than where the individual sales actually land. Here is every October home sale sorted into price bands — and the full table of recorded sales, address by address, updated monthly.
"How much is a house on Nantucket?" has no single answer, so here is the honest one: every 2026 home sale through October 2026 sorted into five budgets, with where those sales closed and what a typical one looked like. Read a row as "with this budget, this is what the market delivered this year" — not as a guarantee about next month.
| Budget | Sales · share | Where they closed (top districts) | Median beds | Median living area | Median $/sq ft | Sold vs. asking |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Under $2M | 29 · 13% | Mid Island (11), Madaket (5), Town (5) | 2 | 1,346 | $1,055 | 92.7% |
| $2M – $3M | 55 · 24% | Town (9), Tom Nevers (7), Miacomet (6) | 3 | 1,805 | $1,421 | 95.2% |
| $3M – $5M | 67 · 29% | Town (18), Surfside (8), Madaket (6) | 4 | 2,627 | $1,534 | 96.5% |
| $5M – $10M | 62 · 27% | Town (23), Cliff (5), Tom Nevers (5) | 5 | 3,850 | $1,818 | 94.6% |
| $10M and above | 17 · 7% | Cliff (4), Surfside (3), Monomoy (3) | 6 | 5,600 | $2,507 | 92.4% |
Source: LINK Nantucket Sales History, January through October 2026 (all 230 recorded home sales — houses, condos, multi-family). Beds, living area and price per square foot come from LINK's sold-listing exports (closings through October 2026) and cover the 228 of 230 sales those exports include; district, price and asking-price capture cover all 230. Sold vs. asking covers the sales that were publicly listed: 52 of the 230 show no marketing period in LINK and an asking price equal to the sale price, which is how a private sale enters the record, and they are left out of that column. Medians, not averages, so one estate sale cannot pull a band.
Every number the charts above are built on, laid out plainly so it can be checked, quoted, and compared month to month. Each line says exactly what it counts, prices are as LINK recorded them, and the data runs through .
| Measure | October 2026 | October 2025 | Change | LINK report |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales closed, all property types | 51 | 65 | −21.5% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Dollar volume, all property types | $280,290,000 | $372,390,000 | −24.7% | Sales History |
| Home sales closed | 46 | 58 | −20.7% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Median home sale price | $4,747,500 | $3,850,000 | +23.3% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Average home sale price | $5,854,348 | $6,080,000 | −3.7% | Market Snapshot |
| Homes: share of asking price captured | 97.18% | — | — | YTD Sales Summary |
| Land parcels sold | 3 | 6 | −50.0% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Median land sale price | $2,440,000 | $2,113,000 | +15.5% | Market Snapshot |
| Active listings at month-end, all property types | 143 | 145 | −1.4% | Inventory Activity |
| New listings, all property types | 34 | 24 | +41.7% | Inventory Activity |
| Listings with a price change | 26 | 21 | +23.8% | Inventory Activity |
| Listings returned to market | 3 | 3 | 0.0% | Inventory Activity |
| Listings taken off market | 24 | 27 | −11.1% | Inventory Activity |
| Measure | 2026 YTD | 2025 YTD | Change | LINK report |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales closed, all property types | 269 | 343 | −21.6% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Dollar volume, all property types | $1,231,270,000 | $1,491,140,000 | −17.4% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Median sale price, all property types | $3,450,000 | $3,150,000 | +9.5% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Average sale price, all property types | $4,577,000 | $4,347,000 | +5.3% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Home sales closed | 230 | 272 | −15.4% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Dollar volume, homes | $1,133,040,000 | $1,283,150,000 | −11.7% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Median home sale price | $3,800,000 | $3,300,000 | +15.2% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Average home sale price | $4,926,000 | $4,717,000 | +4.4% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Homes: share of asking price captured | 96.13% | — | — | YTD Sales Summary |
| Land parcels sold | 30 | 51 | −41.2% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Median land sale price | $1,579,000 | $2,000,000 | −21.1% | YTD Sales Summary |
| Segment | Active listings | Median asking price | New listings in October | Median asking, new listings | Absorption |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Residential | 106 | $5,995,000 | 25 | $3,995,000 | 3 months |
| Land | 16 | $3,250,000 | 7 | $1,800,000 | 5 months |
| Commercial | 14 | $4,950,000 | 0 | — | 14 months |
Cite as: The Kalman Co., Nantucket Real Estate Market Report, data through October 31, 2026, from LINK Nantucket MLS — thekalmanco.com/market-report. A machine-readable copy of these figures lives at /market-report.json. The underlying LINK reports are the 2026 Year-to-Date Sales Summary by Month (run November 3, 2026) and the October 2026 Inventory Activity, Market Snapshot and Sales History.
The median home sale on Nantucket was $4,747,500 in October 2026, up 23.3% from $3,850,000 in October 2025; year to date through October 31, 2026, the median home sale is $3,800,000, up 15.2% across 230 home sales, according to LINK MLS data. One month never tells the whole story — medians move with the mix of what sold, and October's moved because 21 of its 46 home sales closed at $5 million or more — but Nantucket consistently trades among the most expensive housing markets in Massachusetts.
It tightened a third month running in October. Home sales captured 97.2% of asking price by LINK's count, and the 39 that were publicly listed averaged 96.7%, while inventory fell to 143 active listings — the third straight monthly decline, and the lowest month-end count since April — with residential absorption at three months. Sellers who price on evidence hold the advantage; buyers have less to choose from than at any point since spring.
Through October 31, 2026, Nantucket recorded 269 sales across all property types (230 of them homes: houses, condos and multi-family) totaling $1.23 billion, compared with 343 sales for $1.49 billion over the same period in 2025. A typical year sees a few hundred transactions island-wide — a thin market where individual sales can move the monthly numbers.
Three parcels traded in October 2026 at a median of $2,440,000, up 15.5% from $2,113,000 a year earlier, on three sales against six. The largest was 57 Burnell Street in Sconset at $3,000,000, a private sale by LINK's record; 17 Cottage Avenue in Sconset closed at $2,440,000 against a $2,500,000 ask, and 10A Bayberry Lane in Mid Island at $1,650,000. Seven new land listings came to market during the month. Year to date, 30 parcels have sold at a median of $1,579,000.
Through October 2026, 67 of the year's 230 home sales closed between $3M and $5M, most often in Town and Surfside, typically 4 bedrooms and about 2,627 square feet. Just below that, 55 of the year's 230 home sales closed between $2M and $3M, most often in Town and Tom Nevers, typically 3 bedrooms and about 1,805 square feet. Above it, 62 of the year's 230 home sales closed between $5M and $10M, most often in Town and Cliff, typically 5 bedrooms and about 3,850 square feet. Every figure is a median from LINK Nantucket's recorded sales, so one estate sale cannot skew a band; the full budget table on this page shows all five bands.
Monthly. Every figure comes from LINK, Nantucket's MLS, via its monthly sales history, inventory activity, and year-to-date reports. The current edition reflects data through October 31, 2026. Quarterly deep-dives and the annual report are archived on this site as they publish.
Sean Kalman is a sixth-generation Nantucket islander and the founder of The Kalman Co., brokered by eXp Realty. All market data in this report is drawn from LINK Nantucket, the island's MLS. LINK and its members disclaim errors and omissions related to the content of these reports.