THE KALMAN Co.
ListingsKnow NantucketAbout
Contact Sean
← All listings
MLS #93577
Surfside · Active · Listed November 18, 2026

5 Nonantum Avenue

$4,495,000
5 Nonantum Avenue, Nantucket — photo 1 5 Nonantum Avenue, Nantucket — photo 2 5 Nonantum Avenue, Nantucket — photo 3 5 Nonantum Avenue, Nantucket — photo 4
4 photos · select any photo to open it full screen
0.51Acres · 22,215 sq ft
The property

0.51 acres in Surfside.

Just 350 yards from Surfside Beach, 5 Nonantum Avenue sits in one of Nantucket’s most sought-after neighborhoods, where buildable land this close to the south shore rarely comes to market.

Stroll to the beach in minutes and enjoy everything the south shore has to offer right out your front door. The 0.51-acre parcel comes with HDC-approved plans for an impeccable New England coastal style home by Thornewill Design. Main living is all on the first floor beneath a dramatic cathedral ceiling, and a first-floor suite opens onto its own private garden.

Covered porches and a pergola-shaded lounge open to a granite-surrounded pool. Upstairs, the second floor offers two additional primary wings. Skip the design and approval process and go straight to building.

Details

Everything on the record.

StatusActive
ListedNovember 18, 2026
MLS #93577

The property

TypeUnimproved Land
DwellingsPrimary dwelling, secondary allowed

Systems and exterior

GarageNo
Private poolNo
ViewD/Oc, Residential

Land, taxes and fees

Lot0.51 acres (22,215 sq ft)
ZoningR20
SewerSeptic Tank
WaterWell
Annual tax$7,453 · tax year 2026

Want the honest read on this one?

Sean walks these streets. Call or text for the story behind the listing — value, history, and what the photos don't show.

Location

Surfside, on the map.

Full island map →

Listing courtesy of William Raveis Nantucket · Ty Costa. Data from LINK (Listing Information Network, Inc.) as of November 18, 2026. Information believed correct but not guaranteed; buyers should verify all details independently.

Explore
HomeListingsOpen HousesNeighborhood Guides
Insights
Know NantucketTalking NantucketMarket Report
Guides
Buying GuideSelling GuideHome ValuationAll Island Guides
Company
About & TeamContact
THE KALMAN Co.
InstagramFacebookLinkedIn
Nantucket, MA 02554 · 508-228-4578 · sean@thekalmanco.com · Brokered by eXp Realty
© 2026 The Kalman Co. · Equal Housing Opportunity