Cisco: surf, farmland, and the island's laid-back edge.

The island's surf-and-farm corner, minutes from town.

Cisco is where Nantucket goes to surf. Anchored by Cisco Beach, Bartlett's Farm, and the brewery that shares its name, this south-shore neighborhood blends open farmland with newer shingle-style homes built for full summer households. Buyers searching for Cisco Nantucket homes for sale want beach access, space, and an easy run into town.

Much of Cisco's housing stock is newer than the historic core, which means modern layouts, primary-suite footprints, and pools are realistic asks here rather than renovation projects.

Cisco is less a subdivision than a stretch of coast with a culture attached. The name covers the lower run of Hummock Pond Road down to Cisco Beach — the island’s surf break — with Bartlett’s Farm on one shoulder and Cisco Brewers on the other. In LINK’s market data it’s its own statistical area, distinct from the Hummock Pond district just inland, though buyers use the names loosely and the two markets shade into each other along the farm fields.

What sets Cisco apart from the rest of the south shore is the combination of newer housing stock and a genuine daytime scene. Most of the island goes quiet between beach and dinner; Cisco has the farm stand, the brewery crowd, and the surf lineup running all day — and Miacomet Golf Course is minutes away, the course many islanders rank first on the island, with a clubhouse kitchen that draws diners who never touch a club. Buyers here are usually choosing an active summer over a secluded one — and the rental market pays for exactly that.

Cisco’s housing stock is younger than almost any coastal pocket on the island, and it breaks into three recognizable tiers.

Cisco’s market runs on two clocks. The spring market is the busy one — families positioning for the coming summer look hardest between March and June, and the turn-key homes with pools draw the most attention. The off-season is the slow clock, and the honest one: sellers still listed in November are usually sellers with a reason to talk, and this year’s Cisco closings, both negotiated over the winter, settled well under their asking prices.

Structurally, this is a newer-construction market on an island that mostly isn’t. That cuts both ways: Cisco homes carry less renovation risk and rent harder than older stock, but buildable land near the beach is nearly gone, so the premium for finished quality keeps widening. The live listings above are the current picture; the pattern behind them has been consistent for years — scarcity at the beach end, steadier value along the farm corridor.

One more structural note: because the Cisco and Hummock Pond statistical areas split what most buyers think of as one neighborhood, any comp set built on a single area code understates the real market. It’s a detail that changes valuations — and one worth having an agent who knows the line.

From January 1 through August 2026, LINK Nantucket recorded two home sales filed under Cisco. That is too few to call a median; each closing is listed below, against an island-wide home median of $3,650,000 over the same months. Every one was publicly listed, and sellers closed at 78.1% of their asking price on average, after a median of 120 days on the market.

LINK files the neighboring districts under their own names, so they are not in the count above: Hummock Pond (3 sales, $2,645,000 median); Miacomet (9 sales, $2,928,536 median); Surfside (10 sales, $4,450,000 median).

Source: LINK Nantucket Sales History, January–August 2026, every closing filed under Cisco. Homes are counted the way LINK counts them (houses, condos and multi-family), the same 137 sales behind the island-wide median on the market report. Bedrooms and living area come from LINK's sold-listing records; "off-market" marks a sale LINK shows with no marketing period and an asking price equal to its sale price. Every district side by side: the neighborhood table. Every island sale: recent home sales.

Start with the beach walk, not the house. Distance-to-sand is the clearest price axis in Cisco, and a fifteen-minute walk versus a five-minute one separates otherwise similar homes by real money. Decide what your summer actually looks like — surfboard under the arm every morning, or a drive to the beach twice a week — and let that set your row.

Then check the erosion mapping on anything in the first rows, read the septic capacity if a pool is in your plans, and look hard at the shoulder seasons: the homes that hold value best here are the ones that work in June and September, not just August. Pricing sets the pace here: a well-priced house still finds its buyer, an ambitious one waits, and this year’s sales closed well under their asking prices after weeks or months on the market. The buyers who do well in Cisco are the ones who did their thinking before the listing appeared.

Cisco homes for sale

Thinking about buying in Cisco?