THE KALMAN Co.
ListingsKnow NantucketAbout
Contact Sean
Market data · Sold · Updated November 3, 2026

Recent Nantucket home sales

Updated monthly · Data through October 31, 2026 · Source: LINK MLS
By Sean Kalman — The Kalman Co., brokered by eXp Realty. Every recorded sale on the island, its price, and how it closed against the ask — in one table.

The record, in one table

Nantucket real estate transactions become public twice — once at the Registry of Deeds, once through LINK, the island's MLS. This page compiles the LINK record into one readable table, updated every month: every recorded sale, its price, and how it closed against the ask.

Key facts

  • October 2026 closed 51 recorded sales totaling $280,290,000 — the biggest month of 2026 by dollar volume, $40 million clear of September's $240.6M on exactly the same number of sales. (Source: LINK MLS Year-to-Date Sales Summary, October 2026.)
  • 46 of the 51 were homes: $269,300,000 in volume, a median of $4,747,500, an average of $5,854,348. (Source: LINK MLS Sales History, October 2026.)
  • October's home sales averaged 97.2% of final asking price by LINK's count; the 39 that were publicly listed averaged 96.7%, and thirteen of those closed at or above ask. (Source: LINK MLS Sales History, October 2026.)
  • The top sale was 5 Grant Avenue on the Cliff: $35,000,000, a private sale by LINK's record and the largest sale of 2026, ten million clear of 36 Easton Street's $25,000,000 in July. 94 Main Street in Town followed at $15,250,000, one day after it listed at $15,500,000. (Source: LINK MLS Sales History, October 2026.)
  • Three land sales totaled $7,090,000, led by 57 Burnell Street in Sconset at $3,000,000, a private sale; two commercial sales — 122 Pleasant Street in Town at $2,400,000 and Lot A at 1 Toombs Court in Mid Island at $1,500,000 — totaled $3,900,000. (Source: LINK MLS Sales History, October 2026.)
  • Year to date through October: 269 sales for $1.23B, versus 343 sales for $1.49B over the same period of 2025. (Source: LINK MLS Year-to-Date Sales Summary, run November 3, 2026.)

Source: LINK MLS

Early morning sun rising over the harbor at the end of a cobblestone street in downtown Nantucket, lined with gray-shingled buildings and a white picket fence

October 2026: every recorded sale

All 51 MLS-recorded October closings, from LINK's month-end sales history, lowest price first. Sale-to-ask compares the sale price with the asking price at the time of sale; an address links to its listing page where the site carries one.

Address Type Sale price Asking price Sale-to-ask
9 Park Lane, SconsetHome$1,195,000$1,195,000100.00%
1 Toombs Court (LOT A), Mid IslandCommercial$1,500,000$1,500,000100.00%
14 & 16 Sheep Pond Road, MadaketHome$1,500,000$1,599,00093.80%
10A Bayberry Lane, Mid IslandLand$1,650,000$1,795,00091.92%
3 Fayette Street, TownHome$1,725,000$1,865,00092.49%
9 Mary Ann Drive, Mid IslandHome$1,900,000$1,875,000101.33%
15 Goldfinch Drive, NaushopHome$2,050,000$2,175,00094.25%
22 Hooper Farm Road, Mid IslandHome$2,150,000$2,249,00095.59%
7 Clifton Street, SconsetHome$2,200,000$2,650,00083.01%
7 Dooley Court, Mid IslandHome$2,350,000$2,350,000100.00%
106 Old South Road # Unit A Unit B, Mid IslandHome$2,400,000$2,495,00096.19%
122 Pleasant Street, TownCommercial$2,400,000$2,400,000100.00%
17 Cottage Avenue, SconsetLand$2,440,000$2,500,00097.60%
12 Appleton Road, Mid IslandHome$2,500,000$2,575,00097.08%
21 Vesper Lane, South of TownHome$2,650,000$2,750,00096.36%
4 Spinnaker Circle, MiacometHome$2,700,000$2,700,000100.00%
43 Autopscot Circle, NashaquissetHome$2,750,000$2,695,000102.04%
57 Burnell Street, SconsetLand$3,000,000$3,000,000100.00%
30 Pleasant Street, TownHome$3,095,000$3,095,000100.00%
32 Old Tom Nevers Road, Tom NeversHome$3,150,000$3,275,00096.18%
38 Flintlock Road, Tom NeversHome$3,200,000$2,899,000110.38%
4 Fawn Lane, Mid IslandHome$3,200,000$3,699,00086.50%
76 Sankaty Road, SconsetHome$3,450,000$3,450,000100.00%
2 Wood Lily Road, Beach PlumHome$3,775,000$3,775,000100.00%
21 Equator Drive, South of TownHome$3,900,000$3,995,00097.62%
135 Surfside Road, SurfsideHome$4,400,000$4,500,00097.77%
9 Pond View Drive, MiacometHome$4,500,000$4,500,000100.00%
50 Fair Street, TownHome$4,600,000$4,700,00097.87%
54 Fair Street, TownHome$4,895,000$4,895,000100.00%
2 Silver Street, TownHome$4,900,000$5,250,00093.33%
2 Mariner Way, TownHome$5,200,000$5,299,00098.13%
46 Baxter Road, SconsetHome$5,500,000$5,595,00098.30%
23 Pine Street, TownHome$5,695,000$5,695,000100.00%
4 Saccacha Avenue, CiscoHome$5,975,000$5,895,000101.35%
3 Dolphin Court, Brant PointHome$6,050,000$6,200,00097.58%
1 Little Neck Way, MadaketHome$6,150,000$6,250,00098.40%
5 Old Quidnet Milk Route, WauwinetHome$6,300,000$6,950,00090.64%
9 Black Fish Lane, SconsetHome$6,450,000$6,450,000100.00%
42 Chuck Hollow Road, Tom NeversHome$7,200,000$7,900,00091.13%
61 Monomoy Road, MonomoyHome$7,225,000$7,900,00091.45%
43 Vestal Street, West of TownHome$7,300,000$7,995,00091.30%
57 Somerset Road, Hummock PondHome$7,400,000$7,950,00093.08%
42 & 44 Sheep Pond Road, MadaketHome$7,500,000$7,500,000100.00%
26 Wigwam Road, MadequechamHome$8,000,000$8,000,000100.00%
20 West Chester Street, TownHome$8,325,000$8,295,000100.36%
8 Austin Farm Drive, Hummock PondHome$9,650,000$10,195,00094.65%
5 Pilgrim Road, CliffHome$10,750,000$10,750,000100.00%
67 Vestal Street, West of TownHome$11,250,000$11,950,00094.14%
4 Black Walnut Lane, SconsetHome$11,995,000$11,995,000100.00%
94 Main Street, TownHome$15,250,000$15,500,00098.38%
5 Grant Avenue, CliffHome$35,000,000$35,000,000100.00%

Totals: Homes — 46 sales, $269,300,000, average 97.2% of asking by LINK's count; 7 were private sales, which LINK records at their sale price and which read 100% above, and the 39 publicly listed sales averaged 96.7%. Land — 3 sales, $7,090,000. Commercial — 2 sales, $3,900,000. All types — 51 sales, $280,290,000. (Source: LINK MLS Sales History, October 2026.)

The 46 October home sales were 43 houses, one condominium, one co-op and one multi-family property. LINK also recorded three land sales and two commercial sales on the island in October 2026. Its sold export carried no covenant (year-round affordable) home sales in the month.

Sales data provided by LINK (Listing Information Network, Inc.), Nantucket, MA. Information believed correct but not guaranteed; independently verify all details. For consumers' personal, non-commercial use only.

What October's transactions say about the market

October took September's title on the same number of sales: 51 closings for $280.3M against 51 for $240.6M, on 46 home sales against 47. Set against a year ago the count fell — October 2025 closed 65 — and the dollars came in a quarter lighter, because last October was the biggest month of 2025; but the homes that traded this October carried a far higher median, $4,747,500 against $3,850,000, up 23.3%.

The top of the market carried the month. Five sales cleared $10 million — 5 Grant Avenue on the Cliff at $35,000,000, a private sale by LINK's record and the largest sale of the year by ten million dollars; 94 Main Street in Town at $15,250,000, one day after it listed at $15,500,000; 4 Black Walnut Lane in Sconset at its full $11,995,000 ask; 67 Vestal Street in West of Town at $11,250,000; and 5 Pilgrim Road, also on the Cliff, at $10,750,000 — and twenty-one homes closed at $5 million or more, against sixteen in September. The depth again sat in and around Town, where nine of the 46 home sales closed at a $4,900,000 median, from $1,725,000 on Fayette Street to the Main Street sale, with 54 Fair Street taking $4,895,000, its full ask, the day after it listed and 20 West Chester Street closing $30,000 over its $8,295,000 ask.

Pricing discipline showed in the listed sales. The 39 homes that sold after a public listing averaged 96.7% of their last ask, and thirteen closed at or above it — 38 Flintlock Road in Tom Nevers at 110.4%, taking $3,200,000 on a $2,899,000 ask ten days after it listed; 43 Autopscot Circle in Nashaquisset at 102.0%; 4 Saccacha Avenue in Cisco at 101.4%; 9 Mary Ann Drive in Mid Island at 101.3%; 20 West Chester Street in Town just over; and eight right at the number, among them 4 Black Walnut Lane, 54 Fair Street and 9 Park Lane. Seven more were private sales, which LINK records at their sale price; they lift the month's average for all 46 homes to 97.2%. 10 of the listed sellers cut their price at least once before selling, by 8.6% on average, and measured against the original ask the listed group captured 94.6%; the widest miss was 4 Fawn Lane in Mid Island, at 86.5% of a $3,699,000 last ask that had started at $4,299,000.

Land stayed quiet: three lots for a combined $7.1M — 57 Burnell Street in Sconset at $3,000,000, a private sale; 17 Cottage Avenue in Sconset at $2,440,000 against a $2,500,000 ask; and 10A Bayberry Lane in Mid Island at $1,650,000 — at a $2,440,000 median, 15.5% above last October's, and seven new land listings arrived in the month, against none in September. LINK puts land absorption at five months of inventory. Two commercial properties closed: 122 Pleasant Street in Town at $2,400,000 and Lot A at 1 Toombs Court in Mid Island at $1,500,000.

The counterweight moved a third time. The island ended October with 143 active listings, down 7% from September — the third straight monthly decline, and the lowest month-end count since April — and level with a year earlier, with residential absorption at three months, down from five. Fewer homes to choose from, and no slack in what well-priced properties fetch.

How Nantucket sale data becomes public

Every closing is recorded at the Nantucket Registry of Deeds, which is public record. Broker-handled sales are also reported through LINK, which publishes a month-end sales history — the source for the table above. A sale arranged privately, without the MLS, appears only in the registry record, which is one reason the island's off-market layer stays invisible to portals.

This page carries the MLS record. If you're tracking a specific street or property, ask me directly — the registry side can be checked, too.

Put the data to work

The table is only useful if it changes a decision — a price, an offer, a timeline.

If you own on the island, October's numbers are an argument for precision: thirteen of the 39 listed homes closed at or above full ask, eight of them within a week of listing, and the listed group as a whole gave up about three points. The market rewards evidence-based pricing and punishes guesswork. Find out what your home is worth. If you're buying, the table is your comp sheet — and the live island feed is where the next rows come from. For the full monthly analysis behind these numbers, see the market report hub and October's complete write-up.

Questions about any sale above — or the street it's on? Call or text 508-228-4578.

Recent Nantucket sales — frequently asked questions

How do Nantucket real estate transactions become public?

Twice over. Every closing is recorded at the Nantucket Registry of Deeds, which is public record, and broker-handled sales are also reported through LINK, the island's MLS, which publishes month-end sales histories. This page compiles the LINK record each month — addresses, sale prices, asking prices, and property types — through October 31, 2026.

What does "percent of asking" mean?

Sale price divided by the asking price at the time of sale. It measures pricing accuracy: in October 2026, Nantucket home sales averaged 97.2% of asking by LINK's count. That count includes 7 private sales, which LINK records at their sale price; the 39 publicly listed sales averaged 96.7%. Numbers this tight mean sellers priced on evidence and buyers had limited room to negotiate.

How often is this page updated?

Monthly, once LINK publishes its month-end sales history — typically in the first week of the following month. The current table runs through October 31, 2026. For the analysis behind the numbers, the market report hub carries the full monthly write-up, charts, and the year-to-date picture.

Does this table include every Nantucket sale?

It includes every sale recorded through LINK, the island MLS — which covers the broad majority of transactions. Sales arranged privately, without MLS involvement, appear only in the Registry of Deeds record. If you're tracking a specific property or street, ask; the registry side can be checked directly.

What was the biggest Nantucket sale in October 2026?

5 Grant Avenue on the Cliff: $35,000,000, a private sale by LINK's record — the largest sale of 2026, ten million clear of 36 Easton Street's $25,000,000 in July. 94 Main Street in Town followed at $15,250,000, one day after it listed at $15,500,000. The biggest land sale was 57 Burnell Street in Sconset at $3,000,000, and the larger of the two commercial sales was 122 Pleasant Street in Town at $2,400,000.

Where does your house sit in this table?

Request a valuation and Sean will walk you through what the October evidence says your property would actually command.
Request a valuation Call 508-228-4578
About the author

Sean Kalman is a REALTOR® and sixth-generation Nantucketer. The Kalman Co. is brokered by eXp Realty. Reach him at sean@thekalmanco.com or 508-228-4578. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Keep exploring Nantucket real estate.
Market ReportAugust 2026 ReportLive Listings
Explore
HomeListingsOpen HousesNeighborhood Guides
Insights
Know NantucketTalking NantucketMarket Report
Guides
Buying GuideSelling GuideHome ValuationAll Island Guides
Company
About & TeamContact
THE KALMAN Co.
InstagramFacebookLinkedIn
Nantucket, MA 02554 · 508-228-4578 · sean@thekalmanco.com · Brokered by eXp Realty