Buyers who arrive from a gas-heated suburb usually learn how a Nantucket house is heated at the inspection, standing in a basement next to an oil tank. Nothing about it is exotic. It is only different from the mainland in ways that touch the budget, the inspection and, if you ever add solar, the Historic District Commission.
This guide takes it in the order a buyer meets it: the fuel, the electric bill, then the choices. Every rate and rebate below is dated, because all of them reset, most of them in January. None of it is a recommendation of a system or an installer.
Natural gas does not reach Nantucket. There is no pipeline from the mainland and no gas utility on the island, so a house here heats with oil, with propane, or with electricity, and many use two of the three: an oil boiler for heat and hot water with propane for the range and the fireplace, or heat pumps with an older boiler kept behind them.
Oil and propane both arrive by boat and are delivered by truck, which means a tank on the property. A propane tank sits outside, above ground or buried. The oil tank is the one that comes up in a sale.
The cost-of-ownership guide puts heating and electricity in the context of the whole annual budget. What follows is how the pieces work.
Three pieces of Massachusetts law sit behind the oil tank, and a buyer's attorney and insurer know all three.
The first is the release-prevention rule. On a one- to four-unit residential property where an oil supply or return line touches concrete, earth or the floor, the owner must either enclose the supply line in a continuous non-metallic sleeve or have an oil safety valve installed at the tank, with the work certified by a licensed oil burner technician. Lines installed or upgraded since January 1, 1990 that were certified as compliant are exempt, and so is a burner that sits above the tank with its line entirely above the tank's top.
The second is insurance. State law requires homeowners' insurers to make coverage for a heating oil release available: at least $50,000 for cleanup on your own property and $200,000 for third-party claims, with a deductible of no more than $1,000. The state's own guide for homeowners is plain that the coverage is an optional purchase, and an insurer may ask for proof the line upgrade was done before writing it. Ask whether the policy has it.
The third is the buried tank. No underground tank that has held fuel may be removed or relocated without a permit from the fire department, and the standard home inspection does not cover underground tanks at all. If the listing, the seller or an old permit suggests one, that is a separate contract with a separate specialist.
So the questions at inspection are short. Where is the tank, how old is it, has the line been sleeved or valved and is there a certificate, is there release coverage on the policy, and was there ever a tank in the ground. The inspection guide covers what the inspector will and will not test, including a heating system that has been drained for winter and cannot be fired.
Until 1996 every kilowatt used on Nantucket was generated on the island. Today the power arrives on two undersea cables that run about thirty miles from Cape Cod to National Grid's substation on Candle Street. The first, laid in 1996 from Harwich, carries 36 megawatts. The second, laid in 2006 from Hyannis, carries 38. Both belong to Nantucket Electric Company, a National Grid subsidiary, and the town's own filing with the state puts the cable surcharge island customers pay at roughly 15 percent.
The same filing gives the number that matters for reliability: the island's peak load has reached 55 megawatts, more than either cable can carry alone. Behind the cables sit a 6-megawatt Tesla battery at the Bunker Road substation and a 10-megawatt generator. The town has asked National Grid for a timeline on a third cable, which it says may be needed by 2033 at a cost of more than $200 million.
Delivery is National Grid's and you cannot shop it. As of October 1, 2026 the residential delivery rate on Nantucket is 23.178 cents a kilowatt-hour, plus a $10 monthly customer charge.
Supply is the half you can choose. Unless you opt out, a new account is enrolled in Nantucket PowerChoice, the town's electricity aggregation, which has bought power for island customers since 2017. Its supplier is First Point Power, and its prices changed this month: 16.115 cents a kilowatt-hour for the Standard option and 18.815 cents for PowerChoice Green, which is 100 percent renewable, both fixed until November 2027. National Grid's own Basic Service, the alternative, is 17.185 cents through January 31, 2027. You can leave the aggregation at any time without a fee.
Put the halves together and a kilowatt-hour on the Standard option costs about 39 cents this winter. That is the number to carry into any conversation about electric heat.
Mass Save, the state's efficiency program, covers Nantucket through National Grid. Its 2026 rebates for air-source heat pumps come in three sizes. Whole-home, where heat pumps become the sole source of heating and cooling, pays $2,650 a ton up to $8,500. Partial-home, where the old boiler or furnace stays as a supplement, pays $1,125 a ton up to $8,500. Basic pays $250 a ton up to $2,500. The equipment has to be installed in 2026 by a contractor in the Mass Save network, with the paperwork in by February 28, 2027. Income-qualified households have a larger tier.
The whole-home rebate comes with conditions: the house must be sufficiently weatherized first, shown by a home built in 2000 or later or by a Mass Save Home Energy Assessment, and the owner signs a verification form. On January 1, 2027 the amounts drop, to $2,350 a ton capped at $7,500 for whole-home and $1,000 a ton capped at $7,500 for partial-home.
Here is the line second-home owners miss. Mass Save's page says the whole-home and partial-home rebates are available only to residences occupied full time during the winter heating season, and it lists a heat pump in a home that is not occupied in winter, its example is a summer home, under the Basic rebate. A house you close in October is a $2,500 conversation, not an $8,500 one.
Two other pieces. Mass Save's HEAT Loan offers zero-percent financing up to $25,000 for qualified work. And National Grid has a Heat Pump Rate: from November 1 through April 30, a residential customer who heats fully or partly with a heat pump pays a lower delivery rate, 18.877 cents a kilowatt-hour on Nantucket against the standard 23.178, on the tariff effective October 1, 2026. Most systems installed through Mass Save since 2019 are enrolled automatically; anyone else applies with proof of the equipment.
The federal piece is gone. The IRS states that the credit for heat pumps and other efficiency improvements is not allowed for property placed in service after December 31, 2025, and the residential solar credit is not allowed for expenditures made after the same date. Any quote still showing a 30 percent federal credit is out of date.
The whole island is a historic district, so every array that can be seen is an exterior change and needs a Certificate of Appropriateness from the Historic District Commission before it goes up. The Commission's solar guidelines, part of its Sustainable Preservation addendum, are specific. The least visible installation is recommended. Ground arrays, screened where needed, and panels on secondary structures are encouraged over the main house. Panels should sit on the same plane as the roof, in a color in keeping with the roofing. Panels on the primary facade are marked not recommended, and the old historic districts in Town and 'Sconset get a higher level of scrutiny. An owner proposing panels on the main house should be ready to explain why a less visible spot would not work.
In practice rear-facing arrays out of street view are approved routinely, and front-facing ones are the fight: the Select Board upheld the Commission's position against them on appeal in February 2026. One zoning note helps. Ground-mounted solar does not count toward a lot's ground cover.
The town still pays its own rebate. The Nantucket SOLAR Rebate Program, funded through the aggregation, pays $825 per kilowatt of capacity up to $6,000 per household, first come, first served. It is for an owner-occupied primary residence, and it requires a Mass Save home energy assessment within the last three years, six months in PowerChoice before applying, and an application within a year of the system being connected. Massachusetts net metering and the state's SMART incentive remain open to small residential systems; your installer and National Grid handle both.
The cables are reliable and they are also two. In 2024 the island had two major disruptions, by the town's own account: a cable failure in May and a widespread outage on Christmas Stroll weekend. For a year-round house that is an inconvenience. For a house that sits empty in January it is the difference between a cold night and frozen pipes, which is the case for a standby generator, run on propane or diesel since there is no gas line to feed it.
A generator does not count toward ground cover under the zoning bylaw, and the Commission reviews how exterior equipment is screened. More important than the machine is whether anyone knows it ran. Low-temperature alarms and remote monitoring report a problem; a caretaker who walks through the house is the one who fixes it.
For a buyer, before the inspection contingency runs out:
For a seller, the same list is the file. Service records, the oil line certificate, the tank's age, the HDC approval for the array or the condensers, the interconnection letter, a year of bills. A heating system is not a premium in a sale. It is a file, and a complete one keeps the inspection from turning into a negotiation. If you are building new, the choice of system is one your architect and builder will make with the same rebates and the same Commission in mind.