Ask what you can do in your own backyard on Nantucket and the answer often runs through four boards: zoning for what the lot can hold, the Historic District Commission for how it looks, the Board of Health for the septic system, and, on any lot near water, the Conservation Commission. The first three have their own guides on this site. This is the fourth, and for a waterfront or pond-side house it is usually the one that shapes the plan.
I am a broker, not a wetlands scientist, so this is the framework as the town publishes it. The judgment calls belong to a wetlands consultant and the Commission's staff.
Three layers. The Massachusetts Wetlands Protection Act and its regulations set the state floor. Nantucket's Wetlands Bylaw, Chapter 136 of the town code, adopted at Town Meeting in 1983 and amended as recently as 2025, adds local resource areas, values and procedures on top of it. And the Commission's own Wetland Protection Regulations, Chapter 390, carry the detailed standards; the Commission adopted the current version in June 2024 and it took effect on January 1, 2025.
The Commission has seven members appointed by the Select Board to three-year terms. It meets at 5 PM on Thursdays, twice a month, in a hybrid format at the Public Safety Facility on Fairgrounds Road, and its staff sit in the Natural Resources Department at 131 Pleasant Street. The town's own description of the job is review, condition, permit and inspect any project "within 100 feet of any jurisdictional resource area."
The bylaw's list is long on purpose: any bank, freshwater wetland, coastal wetland, beach, dune, flat, marsh, meadow, bog or swamp; any estuary, creek, river, stream, pond or lake; any land subject to tidal action, coastal storm flowage or flooding; the hundred-year storm line; and habitat for rare or significant wildlife, including certified vernal pools. Those areas are protected whether or not they border open water.
Around each of them runs a 100-foot buffer zone, and the rule is simple: nobody may "remove, fill, dredge, alter or build upon" a resource area or within 100 feet of one without a permit from the Commission. Around a great pond, the distance is 200 feet. "Alter" is defined broadly in the regulations and includes cutting trees, changing drainage, placing fill, applying fertilizer outside agricultural use and any work that changes a water table. Clearing brush to open a view is work. So is a path.
Two exemptions are written in: maintaining or replacing existing utility structures, and normal maintenance of land in agricultural use. Normal maintenance of a lawfully existing house and yard is treated under the regulations' definition of a preexisting use.
The performance standards for banks, dunes, vegetated wetlands and the other resource areas share one pattern. Measured from the edge of the resource area:
Houses that stood when the standard was adopted are not required to move. They meet the new setback only when they expand, and only for the area of the expansion. That grandfathering is also written into the waiver section: work that qualifies as a preexisting use gets a waiver as of right.
The 2024 revision also set a filing threshold. Work proposed within 50 feet of a resource area requires a Notice of Intent, the full permit. Work outside 50 feet may qualify for a negative determination, the lighter review, if it stays out of mapped rare-species habitat and vernal pools, does not border an outstanding resource area, uses erosion and sediment controls, and sets a work limit at least 50 feet from any wetland. Septic leaching fields go 100 feet from a wetland, a bank or a dune in every case, and any structure near a vegetated wetland must keep two feet of separation to high groundwater, a rule pools cannot be waived from.
Not everything in the buffer needs a hearing. The regulations let the Commission's staff issue a minor activity permit for small projects outside the 50-foot setback but inside the 100-foot buffer: an unpaved footpath, split-rail fencing that doesn't block wildlife, viewshed management within the Commission's adopted guidelines, planting native trees, shrubs and ground cover (not turf), converting pavement back to vegetation, and taking down a dead or hazardous tree on a certified arborist's say-so. The viewshed guidelines are specific: no shrub cut below four feet, no more than 15 percent of a tree's lower branches removed, all cutting by hand.
The great ponds have a rule of their own. The great pond area is the 200 feet landward of a pond's mean annual high water line. It carries no buffer zone, but every project within it files a minor activity request before work starts, and the Commission evaluates the work for keeping a continuous corridor of native habitat to the pond. Where the pond's own bank or bordering wetland is present, those stricter standards apply as well.
On the shore the buffer bands are the same, and several standards sit on top of them. On an eroding coastal bank, a new structure must stand back at least 20 times the average annual erosion rate, or 100 feet, whichever is less, with the rate figured over 150 years and checked against the last ten in case erosion has accelerated. New bulkheads, revetments and groins to protect buildings constructed or substantially improved after August 1978 are not permitted, and every permit for a new or substantially improved house within 100 feet of the top of a bank carries the condition that no coastal engineering structure may be built later to protect it. No building goes on a coastal dune or within 50 feet of one. In land subject to coastal storm flowage, septic systems and private underground fuel tanks must sit outside the hundred-year floodplain, building where storms or high tides would reach it may not be permitted at all, and every swimming pool must be designed so it can never interact with floodwater. The coastal erosion guide walks through what a moving shoreline does to a lot.
A Request for Determination of Applicability asks the Commission one question: does the bylaw apply to this land or this work? You file it in writing, the Commission publishes notice of its meeting at least five days ahead at your expense, you mail notice to every abutter on the Assessor's certified list by certified mail, and the Commission answers in writing within 21 days. The answer can be that the work is in jurisdiction but limited enough that no permit is needed, which is the outcome most small projects outside the 50-foot line are looking for.
A Notice of Intent is the application for a permit. Nantucket's version is filed together with the state's Notice of Intent, carries its own town fee and advertising fee, and must come after or alongside every other approval the project needs; the town is explicit that applicants should have applied for or obtained their HDC, Planning Board, Zoning Board and Board of Health permits first. The filing is a stamped plan set: wetland delineations with the flags shown, a locus map, the 50 and 100-foot lines, two-foot contours, erosion controls, a work limit, the FEMA zone, and the deed or certificate of title. The Commission holds a hearing within 21 days of receiving it and issues or denies the permit within 21 days of the hearing. The burden of proof is yours: the bylaw says the applicant must show by a preponderance of the evidence that the work will not harm the protected interests, and the Commission may hire a consultant to review the application at your cost, capped at $2,500 for a house.
The fee schedule published with the regulations lists a Request for Determination at $150, a Notice of Intent for additions and site work at $200 and for a new house at $300, a certificate of compliance at $125 and a minor activity application at $50. Filing after the fact costs double, and ten times the fee if the Commission is already enforcing. Confirm the current schedule with the office before you file.
A permit arrives as an Order of Conditions: the work as approved, with whatever conditions the Commission attaches. It lasts three years, can be extended for three one-year periods if you ask at least 30 days before it expires, and must be recorded at the Registry of Deeds or the Land Court, in the chain of title, before any work begins. Plan changes go back to the Commission in writing; it decides whether they are minor or need a new filing. An aggrieved party has 20 days to take an Order to Superior Court. A denied project cannot be refiled for three years unless circumstances have materially changed.
When the work is done, the Order has to be closed. Within 21 days of the Building Commissioner issuing an occupancy permit, the applicant applies for a certificate of compliance, with an as-built plan and, for engineered projects, a professional's statement of substantial compliance. The Commission may walk the site before signing. The certificate is recorded in the chain of title like the Order, and failing to apply for it is itself a violation, with fines of up to $300 a day.
Because Orders and certificates are recorded, a title search shows them, and a careful attorney reads the sequence: every Order of Conditions on the property should be matched by a certificate of compliance. An open Order means work was permitted and never closed out. Work with no Order behind it is the more serious finding, because the bylaw says a person who buys land on which work was done in violation must comply with any enforcement order or restore the land, and the town has three years from the purchase to act. That history is worth knowing before you make an offer, not after.
The second question is what the lot can still do. Where the resource areas and the 25, 50, 75 and 100-foot lines fall decides whether the addition, the pool or the guest house a buyer is imagining is possible, and a current wetland delineation is the only reliable way to know. For a waterfront house, pair this guide with the flood zone, the erosion history and the insurance picture; the waterfront guide covers all four.